Search

Research Spotlight: Whey vs. plant proteins

Research Spotlight articles share concise breakdowns of interesting studies. The study reviewed is "Differential Responses of Blood Essential Amino Acid Levels Following Ingestion of High-Quality Plant-Based Protein Blends Compared to Whey Protein-A Double-Blind Randomized, Cross-Over, Clinical Trial" by Brennan et al.

Post-meal increases in leucine play a critical role in stimulating muscle protein synthesis, and therefore supporting the growth and maintenance of muscle mass. Similarly, plasma essential amino acids (EAAs) play an important role in supporting muscle growth.

In the current study, the authors compared post-meal amino acid levels after subjects consumed whey or three separate plant-based protein blends. All four treatments had the same total amount of leucine, EAAs, and a protein digestibility corrected amino (PDCAA) score of 1.0. As a result, the plant proteins required a total protein dose of 33-34g, while subjects consumed only 24g of whey.

In the 4 hours after feeding, plasma peak leucine and EAA values were significantly higher for whey protein than for all other proteins. While the plant proteins were safe, well-tolerated, and caused notable increases in plasma leucine and EAAs, they were not equivalent to whey.

The bottom line: There’s absolutely nothing wrong with plant proteins, and it’s important to remember that this study did not directly measure hypertrophy, or even protein synthesis. However, this study seems to add a little more evidence to the literature suggesting that lifters on plant-based diets may want to shoot for relatively higher protein intakes if hoping to maximize muscle mass.

Read this article for more information on plant-based diets for lifters.

Stay up to date with the latest research

Get short, skimmable summaries of new important research with the SBS Research Spotlight newsletter. It’s the easiest way to learn about the latest exercise and nutrition research. New editions sent twice a month. Sign up here (it’s totally free).

Scroll to Top